Life Domains Vision Eval

Phase

Vision_Eval

Run

• Date: 2026-07-17
• Department: Product
• Project: Product/Life_Domains
• Evaluator role: Forge Project Evaluator
• Skill: project-vision-eval
• Phase file checked: Product/Projects/Life_Domains/Life_Domains_Phase.md
• Vision document checked: Product/Projects/Life_Domains/Life_Domains_Vision.md
• Existing Vision Eval report: reviewed and superseded by this run
• Run / cost evidence: exact token, cost, and agent-job metadata unavailable in this session. Available evidence: conversation-driven evaluator run on 2026-07-17; npm run build attempted from /workspace/forge@uvilo.com/uvilo-os and failed because the root package.json has no build script.

Verdict

Approved

Checklist

Item	Result	Note
Clarity	✅	The Vision states the project purpose, canonical 14-domain scope, metadata fields, conditional domains, output expectations, update process, success criteria, and out-of-scope areas in terms a downstream reader can understand.
Testability	✅	Requirements and success criteria are verifiable through document inspection, schema validation, JSON output checks, downstream reference checks, and skill/documentation review.
Non-contradiction	✅	The requirements are mutually consistent: schema validation, tag coverage, conditional-domain handling, canonical output, and skill maintenance support the same domain-reference objective.
Completeness	✅	The Vision covers the stated project scope: publishing canonical domain metadata, enforcing a schema, validating tag coverage, documenting conditional-domain applicability, producing machine-readable output, and maintaining a domain metadata workflow.
Charter considerations	✅	Stewardship is relevant and addressed through stable identifiers, versioned migration expectations, validation, and downstream communication. Security, privacy, and performance tracking are not directly in scope for this domain-metadata project as written.
Work-product communication	✅	Material Vision requirements, scope, success criteria, exclusions, and charter considerations are present in the durable Vision artifact rather than only in conversation.

Resolution Log

Round	Action	Result
0	Evaluator inspected the Vision document and existing Vision Eval report.	The prior rejection no longer applies because the Vision now contains substantive project scope, requirements, success criteria, out-of-scope boundaries, and charter considerations.
0	Evaluator applied the project-vision-eval checklist.	No Vision findings were identified.
0	Auto-fix consideration.	Not needed because the Vision passed evaluation.
0	Build validation.	Attempted npm run build; command failed because the root package.json has no build script. This is recorded as run evidence and did not create a Vision finding.

Notes

No Items table is included because the Verdict is Approved and no Vision findings remain.

Disposition

Vision_Eval is approved for Product/Life_Domains.

Next Step

Advance from Vision_Eval to Research according to the Forge project routing table, unless a separate human gate or runner decision intervenes.