Knowledge Consistency Execute Eval 7

Evaluation of Plan 7 implementation for Plan cycle 7.

---

Run — 2026-07-24

Phase

Execute_Eval_7

Agent / Session Context

Field	Value
Evaluator bot	forge/project-evaluator
Evaluator conversation	exact conversation id unavailable in tool context
Project	Forge/Knowledge_Consistency
Plan	Plan 7 — Bot Prompts, Available Skills, and Follow-ups
Previous phase confirmed	Execute_7_Completed in Knowledge_Consistency_Phase.md before evaluation start
Evaluation phase started	Execute_Eval_7_Started in commit 5972bcd
Execution commits evaluated	501a40e, be146a8
Database work-products evaluated	Prompt records prm_cmq8aja9i000301mzab1ezdxf, prm_cmqmmf7vr000b01p15biyasvf, prm_cmqmkjxc6000u01o6ddc7p9kn, prm_cmqmgkp1v000o01o6kc6b8t6m, prm_cmq83857c000101mzrhmopc03; todo records tdi_cmrz5r77a002p01nyz0loxqxl, tdi_cmrz5r77p002q01ny6y8io3xq

Verdict

Approved

The Plan 7 implementation is approved after one evaluator auto-fix. All Plan 7 file, prompt, build, and follow-up requirements are satisfied at the end of evaluation. The single issue found was a mechanical gap in the two follow-up todo item bodies: they initially omitted the **Status:** Open field specified by Plan 7 Task 8. The evaluator updated both todo item bodies directly and re-verified them. No open findings remain.

Implementation Summary

Task	Status	Notes
Task 1 — Update Project Runner Bot Prompt	✅	Project Runner prompt version 21 lists default gates Vision_Eval, Spec_Eval, Plan_Eval, Verify; its Phase Naming Convention removes Pending from agent-set statuses; _Pending handling is absent; autonomous routing leaves the next phase unset and spawns the responsible agent to set _Started.
Task 2 — Update Project Worker Bot Prompt	✅	Project Worker prompt version 8 has Work-Product Path or Link, instructs spawning the Page Manager bot for page/sidebar/frontmatter operations, and has publishedAt: 2026-07-24T16:28:00.000Z.
Task 3 — Update Project Evaluator Bot Prompt	✅	Project Evaluator prompt version 13 instructs spawning the Page Manager bot via spawnAgent with { botGroup: 'forge', botHandle: 'page-manager' }; no “manage-pages skill” reference remains in the active prompt text.
Task 4 — Fix Page Manager Bot Prompt Tool Name	✅	Page Manager prompt version 3 references forge-filesystem and does not reference uvilo-filesystem.
Task 5 — Update Available Skills List in Persistent Knowledge Prompt	✅	Persistent Knowledge prompt version 5 lists all 24 published Forge/Skills/ folders and excludes the three draft MCP skills. Required additions (agentic-prompts, artifacts-markdown, audit-context, choose-ai-model, start-astro-dev, test-tools) are present; removed entries (orchestration, mongodb, Linear_MCP, Suprsend_MCP, Vercel_MCP) are absent from the active list.
Task 6 — Remove MCP References from Documentation	✅	A documentation search under Forge/ excluding the three MCP skill folders, archived projects, and current project documents found no Linear_MCP, Suprsend_MCP, or Vercel_MCP references in active documentation.
Task 7 — Ensure Run/Cost Evidence in Handoff Packets and Runs Document	✅	Project Runner, Project Thinker, Project Evaluator, and Project Worker prompts have Run / Cost Evidence in their Standard Handoff Packet tables. Page Manager and Task Runner do not produce handoff packets. Project_Verify/SKILL.md now instructs generating {Project}_Runs.md during Verify even when exact evidence is unavailable.
Task 8 — Create Follow-up Todo Items for Platform Code Changes	✅	Todo items tdi_cmrz5r77a002p01nyz0loxqxl and tdi_cmrz5r77p002q01ny6y8io3xq exist, are user-owned, reference the relevant Spec sections, and after auto-fix include the Task 8 body fields including **Status:** Open.
Task 9 — Build, Commit, and Push	✅	Execution file changes were committed in 501a40e and final phase/changelog updates in be146a8, both pushed to dev. Root npm run build failed because no root build script exists; .internal build succeeded with 940 pages during execution and evaluation.

Checklist / Evidence

Check	Evidence	Result
Previous phase complete	Phase file showed Phase: Execute_7_Completed before evaluator set Execute_Eval_7_Started.	✅
Evaluator phase started	Phase file updated to Execute_Eval_7_Started and committed/pushed as 5972bcd.	✅
Project Runner prompt requirements	Active prompt prm_cmq8aja9i000301mzab1ezdxf version 21 contains default gates Vision_Eval, Spec_Eval, Plan_Eval, Verify; no _Pending branch; routing says to leave the next phase unset and spawn the agent; Phase Naming Convention no longer lists Pending.	✅
Project Worker prompt requirements	Active prompt prm_cmqmmf7vr000b01p15biyasvf version 8 has Work-Product Path or Link, Page Manager spawn instruction, and a non-null publishedAt timestamp.	✅
Project Evaluator prompt requirements	Active prompt prm_cmqmkjxc6000u01o6ddc7p9kn version 13 has Page Manager spawn instruction and no active “manage-pages skill” instruction.	✅
Page Manager prompt requirements	Active prompt prm_cmqmgkp1v000o01o6kc6b8t6m version 3 lists forge-filesystem; uvilo-filesystem is absent.	✅
Persistent Knowledge Available Skills	Active prompt prm_cmq83857c000101mzrhmopc03 version 5 includes all 24 published skills found in Forge/Skills/ and excludes Linear_MCP, Suprsend_MCP, and Vercel_MCP, which remain status: draft on disk.	✅
MCP documentation references	`grep -RIlE ‘Linear_MCP	Suprsend_MCP
Run/Cost Evidence handoff fields	Active Project Runner, Project Thinker, Project Evaluator, and Project Worker prompts include the Run / Cost Evidence row with the expected fallback purpose.	✅
Verify Runs document instruction	Forge/Forge_Project/Skills/Project_Verify/SKILL.md procedure step 7 instructs generating {Project}_Runs.md and recording available run/cost context even when exact data is unavailable.	✅
Follow-up todos	Todo item tdi_cmrz5r77a002p01nyz0loxqxl requests the application/vnd.git-changes two-commit diff enhancement and references Spec Section 11.1. Todo item tdi_cmrz5r77p002q01ny6y8io3xq requests conversation-tool usage fields and references Spec Section 11.2. Both are on user todo list tdl_cmqjm0ui6000922uyc5yj6o9w.	✅
Build	Root npm run build failed with missing root script, matching known infrastructure context. .internal build succeeded during evaluation with 940 pages.	✅
Git	Evaluated execution commits 501a40e and be146a8; evaluator start commit 5972bcd is pushed on dev; working tree was clean after evaluator start commit.	✅
Changelog checklist	Plan 7 Changelog rows identify the five modified prompt records and Project_Verify/SKILL.md, and align with Plan 7 task intent.	✅
Work-product communication	Execute_State_7 contains the full execution log, task completion evidence, todo ids, prompt ids, build notes, and commit/push notes; no material Plan 7 implementation result was found only in conversation.	✅

Items

#	Type	Description	Status	Disposition
E1	Gap	Plan 7 Task 8 specified that each follow-up todo body include **Status:** Open. The two created todo bodies initially included project, phase, requesting role, action, rationale, and work-product link, but omitted the explicit Status field.	🟢 Resolved	Fix

Resolution Log

#	Disposition	Action taken	Resolved
E1	Fix	Auto-dispositioned. Updated todo items tdi_cmrz5r77a002p01nyz0loxqxl and tdi_cmrz5r77p002q01ny6y8io3xq to add **Status:** Open before their work-product links while preserving ownership, state, and Spec references. Re-read both updated todo records; both now contain the required Status field.	Yes

Run / Cost Evidence

Exact token/cost data is unavailable from the evaluator session. Available evidence:

• Evaluator conversation id: exact id unavailable in tool context
• Evaluator start commit: 5972bcd
• Evaluated execution commits: 501a40e, be146a8
• Prompt/database evidence: Project Runner version 21; Project Worker version 8; Project Evaluator version 13; Page Manager version 3; Persistent Knowledge version 5; Project Thinker version 5; Task Runner version 3
• Todo evidence: tdi_cmrz5r77a002p01nyz0loxqxl and tdi_cmrz5r77p002q01ny6y8io3xq, updated during evaluation to include **Status:** Open
• Build evidence: root npm run build failed due to missing root build script; .internal build succeeded with 940 pages
• Current branch: dev; evaluator start commit pushed to origin

Next Step

Set Knowledge_Consistency_Plan_7.md, Knowledge_Consistency_Execute_State_7.md, and this report to status: approved; set the project Phase to Execute_Eval_7_Completed; because Execute_Eval is not listed in this project’s human_gates and there are no additional Plans, route autonomously to Verify.