Knowledge Consistency Execute Eval 8

Evaluation of Plan 8 implementation for Plan cycle 8.

---

Run — 2026-07-31

Agent / Session Context

Field	Value
Department	Forge
Project	Forge/Knowledge_Consistency
Phase	Execute_Eval_8
Plan	Plan 8 — Post-Verify Stale Reference Cleanup
Evaluator Role	forge/project-evaluator
Skill	Project_Execute_Eval
Plan Document	Forge/Projects/Knowledge_Consistency/Knowledge_Consistency_Plan_8.md
Execute State	Forge/Projects/Knowledge_Consistency/Knowledge_Consistency_Execute_State_8.md
Prior Work-Products Checked	Vision, Vision_Eval, Research, Spec, Spec_Eval, Plans 1–8, Execute_State_8
Execution Commits Reviewed	abdd564 (Plan 8 source/work-product changes), c8a6275 (Changelog update)

Verdict

Approved.

Plan 8 content changes satisfy the Plan intent for verification findings E2–E8. E9 was already resolved before this Plan, and E10 is covered by Plan 8’s comprehensive E2–E8 cleanup. No re-execution is required.

Implementation Summary

Task	Status	Notes
Task 1 — Fix Forge_Infrastructure.md (E2, E3, E4, E5)	✅	MongoDB/MONGO_URI references removed from the specified file, JWT Auth Manager replaced with API-key authentication, obsolete unprefixed discovery tool names removed, and incorrect workspace path removed.
Task 2 — Fix infrastructure_state.md (E2)	✅	MongoDB service row and MONGO_URI row removed.
Task 3 — Fix Project_Rename/SKILL.md (E5)	✅	Incorrect /workspace/erik/uvilo-os path replaced with [[orgRepoRoot]]/ in the grep example.
Task 4 — Fix Forge Optimizer reference files (E6, E7, E4)	✅	Forge_Chat_Prompt references and obsolete get_skill_details usage removed from the target files; Page Manager spawn pattern present in example_report.md.
Task 5 — Fix project skills and workflow (E6)	✅	Targeted Forge_Chat_Prompt references removed from Project Extract, Project Extract Eval, and Forge Project Workflow files.
Task 6 — Fix model-specific names in Typesense skills (E8)	✅	gpt-5.4-nano and gpt-4o-mini references removed from the two target skills; use-case wording and Choose_AI_Model/Models/ folder reference present.
Task 7 — Build, commit, and push	✅ with resolved variance	Commits abdd564 and c8a6275 are on dev and pushed. The exact Plan command npm run build --prefix .internal fails at pre-existing astro check TypeScript/module declaration errors in Search.astro; the execution’s substituted npm run generate && npx astro build was re-run and succeeded with 951 pages. See item EE8-1.

Verification Checklist

Check	Evidence	Result
E2 — no MongoDB/MONGO_URI references in Forge/Forge_Infrastructure.md	grep -in 'mongodb|MONGO_URI|mongo' Forge/Forge_Infrastructure.md returned no matches.	✅
E2 — no MongoDB/MONGO_URI references in infrastructure_state.md	grep -in 'mongodb|MONGO_URI|mongo' Forge/Skills/Update_Infrastructure/references/infrastructure_state.md returned no matches.	✅
E3 — no JWT Auth Manager in Forge_Infrastructure.md	grep -in 'JWT Auth Manager' Forge/Forge_Infrastructure.md returned no matches.	✅
E3 — API-key authentication present	grep -n 'API-key authentication' Forge/Forge_Infrastructure.md returned line 46.	✅
E4 — no obsolete unprefixed discovery tool names in targets	`grep -nP ’(?<!forge-discovery__)(list_skills	find_skill
E5 — no incorrect workspace path in targets	grep -n '/workspace/erik/uvilo-os' Forge/Forge_Infrastructure.md Forge/Forge_Project/Skills/Project_Rename/SKILL.md returned no matches.	✅
E6 — no Forge_Chat_Prompt in the five target files	grep -rn 'Forge_Chat_Prompt' across the target files returned no matches.	✅
E7 — no Manage Pages skill routing language in example_report.md	grep -in 'Manage Pages skill|manage.pages skill|manage-pages skill' Forge/Skills/Forge_Optimizer/references/example_report.md returned no matches.	✅
E7 — Page Manager spawn pattern present	grep -n "botGroup: 'forge', botHandle: 'page-manager'" Forge/Skills/Forge_Optimizer/references/example_report.md returned line 20.	✅
E8 — no model-specific names in the two Typesense skills	grep -rn 'gpt-5.4-nano|gpt-4o-mini' Forge/Skills/Reindex_Typesense/SKILL.md Forge/Skills/Typesense_MCP/SKILL.md returned no matches.	✅
E8 — indexing use-case wording present	grep -n 'indexing use case' returned matches in both target skills.	✅
Git pushed	git rev-parse HEAD and git rev-parse origin/dev both returned c8a62757f57ce1595df90f695303317e840cf8cc; git rev-list --left-right --count origin/dev...HEAD returned 0 0.	✅
Changed files align with Plan intent	git show --name-only abdd564 contains the 10 planned source files plus expected project workflow files (Execute_State_8, Phase, Plan 8, Plan_Eval_8); c8a6275 contains the Changelog update.	✅

Items

#	Type	Description	Status	Disposition
EE8-1	Variance	Plan Task 7 specified npm run build --prefix .internal should succeed. Re-run during evaluation failed at astro check because of pre-existing TypeScript/module declaration errors in .internal/src/components/Search.astro (virtual:starlight/docsearch-config and typesense-docsearch.js/dist/umd/index.js). The changed Plan 8 files are documentation/skill markdown files and do not touch Search.astro; npm run generate && npx astro build succeeded with 951 pages.	🟢 Resolved	Auto-dispositioned — accepted variance; no Plan 8 fix required

Resolution Log

#	Disposition	Action taken	Resolved
EE8-1	Auto-dispositioned accepted variance	Recorded the exact build-script failure and successful site build evidence. No code/document fix was applied because the failing astro check diagnostics are pre-existing infrastructure issues outside Plan 8’s changed files and Plan 8’s content verification criteria passed.	Yes

Run / Cost Evidence

Exact model token/cost data for the Project Worker execution and this evaluation session is unavailable in the repo. Available evidence:

• Worker-reported execution commits: abdd564 and c8a6275.
• Current local/remote HEAD at evaluation start: c8a62757f57ce1595df90f695303317e840cf8cc.
• Build check attempted by evaluator: npm run build --prefix .internal failed during astro check with two pre-existing Search.astro errors.
• Build artifact check attempted by evaluator: npm run generate && npx astro build from .internal/ succeeded and built 951 pages.
• Direct grep verification commands are recorded in the Verification Checklist above.

Notes

• The Changelog includes Plan 8 entries for the 10 planned source files plus Knowledge_Consistency_Execute_State_8.md and Knowledge_Consistency_Phase.md. The Plan 8 and Plan_Eval_8 work-products were also present in commit abdd564 as expected workflow records.
• Knowledge_Consistency_Learnings.md contains no active learning entries to incorporate.
• Execute_Eval is not listed in human_gates; after this report is committed and the phase is set to Execute_Eval_8_Completed, routing should proceed autonomously to Verify re-check.

Next Step

Set Phase: Execute_Eval_8_Completed and route to Project Verify for the post-Plan-8 verification re-check.