Knowledge Consistency Verification
Run — 2026-07-24
Phase
Project: Forge/Knowledge_Consistency
Phase evaluated: Verify
Starting phase evidence: Knowledge_Consistency_Phase.md was Execute_Eval_7_Completed; project discovery showed Execute_Eval reports 1–7 with status: approved; user stated Plan 7 is final and all Plans 1–7 completed Execute_Eval.
Verifier context: fresh Project Evaluator verification context for this run. The verification context read only the Phase file, Project_Verify skill, Vision, Spec, Changelog, the verification template, prompt/database records required to verify Spec prompt criteria, and direct implementation artifacts/grep evidence needed to test the Spec. It did not read Research, Plans, Learnings, or Execute_State files.
Disposition
Blocked. Verification found open Spec/implementation consistency defects after one mechanical auto-fix. Findings exceed five items, so the recommended next step is a new Plan rather than further direct verification-phase repair.
Build / Commit / Push Evidence
- Start phase was set to
Verify_Started, built withnpm run build --prefix .internal, committed asb62aeaa(Start Knowledge Consistency verification), and pushed toorigin/dev. - Verification report and Runs document were generated after verification checks.
- Exact model token/cost data is unavailable from the current conversation tools; see
Knowledge_Consistency_Runs.mdfor available run/cost context.
Success Criteria
| # | Criterion | Measured by | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| V1 | All Forge Knowledge files reviewed | Checklist of every published .md file in Forge department root and Functions | 🔴 Open |
| V2 | All forge-group Bot system prompts reviewed | Checklist of every Bot in the “forge” group | 🟢 Success |
| V3 | All Forge Skills reviewed | Checklist of every SKILL.md in the Forge department | 🔴 Open |
| V4 | Deprecated items listed with file references | Itemized list with file path and removal recommendation | 🔴 Open |
| V5 | Outdated items listed with file references | Itemized list with file path, what’s outdated, and update recommendation | 🔴 Open |
| V6 | Inconsistencies listed with cross-references | Itemized list citing conflicting sources side by side | 🔴 Open |
| V7 | Omissions listed (documented-but-unimplemented and implemented-but-undocumented) | Itemized list with file references | 🔴 Open |
| V8 | Charter contradictions/omissions listed | Itemized list citing Charter section vs. conflicting source | 🔴 Open |
| V9 | Recommendations presented for user approval | Categorized findings document with recommended actions | 🟢 Success |
| V10 | Spec created for approved fixes | Spec document covering each approved recommendation | 🟢 Success |
Success Criteria Notes
- V2 is successful for the prompt records explicitly named in the Spec and the additional stale Persistent Knowledge prompt defect found during Verify; the only prompt defect found was auto-fixed in this run.
- V1, V3, V4, V5, V6, V7, and V8 remain open because verification found stale or contradictory content remaining in Knowledge and Skills.
- V9 and V10 remain successful because the Vision, Spec, and Changelog exist and the Spec covers the approved recommendations at project-planning time. The final implementation does not yet fully satisfy the Spec as a whole.
Verification Evidence Summary
| Check Area | Evidence | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Project phase gate | Phase file started at Execute_Eval_7_Completed; discovery reported Execute_Eval 1–7 files with status: approved | 🟢 Pass |
| Build before verification | npm run build --prefix .internal completed successfully during Verify start; build generated 940 pages in prior Plan 7 evidence and succeeded in this run | 🟢 Pass |
| Skills inventory | Node verification script found 24 published skills and draft skills Linear_MCP, Suprsend_MCP, Vercel_MCP | 🟢 Pass |
Agentic_Prompts rename | Forge/Skills/Agentic_Prompts/SKILL.md exists; Forge/Skills/Orchestration absent | 🟢 Pass |
Update_Infrastructure currency | Skill contains docs/deployment.md and uvilo-mono, with no case-insensitive outdated warning | 🟢 Pass |
Discovery table in Forge_Agent_Orchestration.md | All six current names present: forge-discovery__list_departments, forge-discovery__list_dept_projects, forge-discovery__get_project, forge-discovery__list_skills, forge-discovery__get_skill, forge-discovery__find; obsolete names absent from that file | 🟢 Pass |
| Root knowledge frontmatter | Six target root knowledge files have status: published; target frontmatter has no created, updated, or lastUpdated; target files have approver | 🟢 Pass |
| Prompt inspectability docs | Forge_Agent_Architecture.md contains application/vnd.prompt-version and unified text diff | 🟢 Pass |
| README consolidation | Forge/README.md and Forge/Forge_Project/README.md are absent; Knowledge_Consistency_README_Consolidation.md exists | 🟢 Pass |
| Phase-state Pending removal | User Guide, Workflow, and Project_Flow skill have no _Pending / phase-state Pending pattern | 🟢 Pass |
| Runs generation skill update | Project_Verify/SKILL.md contains {Project}_Runs.md generation and run/cost evidence language | 🟢 Pass |
| Persistent Knowledge prompt stale tool name | searchPrompts("get_skill_details") found Persistent Knowledge; auto-fixed to forge-discovery__get_skill; post-fix search returned zero prompt results | 🟢 Resolved |
| Remaining stale terms | Targeted grep still found stale Forge_Chat_Prompt, LibreChat, MongoDB, wrong workspace path, JWT Auth Manager, obsolete discovery tools, and model-specific references outside the intended locations | 🔴 Fail |
Items
| # | Type | Description | Status | Disposition |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| E1 | Defect | Persistent Knowledge prompt used nonexistent discovery tool. Prompt prm_cmq83857c000101mzrhmopc03 said to use forge-discovery__get_skill_details, but the actual/current tool is forge-discovery__get_skill. | 🟢 Resolved | Fix |
| E2 | Defect | MongoDB references remain in Knowledge/Skill reference docs despite Spec S1.8. Examples include Forge/Forge_Infrastructure.md architecture and env var table (MongoDB, MONGO_URI) and Forge/Skills/Update_Infrastructure/references/infrastructure_state.md. Spec says no skill or knowledge file references MongoDB and MongoDB has been removed. | 🔴 Open | — |
| E3 | Defect | Forge_Infrastructure.md still documents JWT Auth Manager for session auth. This conflicts with the current API-key/service-account authentication language required by Spec S4.4 and used elsewhere. | 🔴 Open | — |
| E4 | Defect | Forge_Infrastructure.md still lists obsolete forge-discovery tool names. The MCP details section says list_skills, find_skill, and get_skill_details; Spec S1.6 requires the current forge-discovery__* tool names and specifically forge-discovery__get_skill, not get_skill_details. | 🔴 Open | — |
| E5 | Defect | Incorrect workspace path remains. Grep found /workspace/erik/uvilo-os/ in Forge/Forge_Infrastructure.md, Forge/Forge_Project/Skills/Project_Rename/SKILL.md, and old Forge/Output/Verify_Infra_* documents. Spec S1.5 says no file references that incorrect path. | 🔴 Open | — |
| E6 | Defect | Deprecated Forge_Chat_Prompt.md references remain. Grep found remaining references in Forge/Skills/Forge_Optimizer/references/example_report.md, Forge/Skills/Forge_Optimizer/references/extraction_prompt.md, Forge/Forge_Project/Skills/Project_Extract/SKILL.md, Forge/Forge_Project/Skills/Project_Extract_Eval/SKILL.md, and Forge/Forge_Project/Forge_Project_Workflow.md. The file no longer exists and the prompt lives in the Bot database. | 🔴 Open | — |
| E7 | Defect | Direct Manage Pages skill routing remains in a skill reference example. Forge/Skills/Forge_Optimizer/references/example_report.md still recommends Follow the Manage Pages skill procedure; Spec S1.10 requires Page Manager bot spawning instead of direct skill-routing language. | 🔴 Open | — |
| E8 | Defect | Model-specific names remain outside the intended Choose_AI_Model boundary. Forge/Skills/Reindex_Typesense/SKILL.md and Forge/Skills/Typesense_MCP/SKILL.md still instruct agents to consult gpt-5.4-nano model files directly. Spec S7.2-S7.3 require skills/docs to use use-case names and keep model-specific quirks in Choose_AI_Model model references. | 🔴 Open | — |
| E9 | Variance | LibreChat-era documentation remains in Forge Output docs. Forge/Output/Admin_Panel_Plan.md and Forge/Output/Verify_Infra_2026_04_25.md / Verify_Infra_2026_05_07.md contain LibreChat-era architecture, librechat.yaml, MongoDB, and old URL references. If Forge/Output is intentionally historical, this needs an explicit scope/status decision; otherwise it conflicts with the project’s currency goal. | 🔴 Open | — |
| E10 | Gap | Spec coverage did not account for several remaining stale sources. The approved Spec identified many targets but missed or under-specified stale references in Forge_Infrastructure, Project_Extract, Project_Extract_Eval, Project_Rename, Forge_Optimizer reference files, and Output docs. | 🔴 Open | — |
Resolution Log
| # | Disposition | Action taken | Resolved |
|---|---|---|---|
| E1 | Fix | Updated prompt prm_cmq83857c000101mzrhmopc03 (Persistent Knowledge) to replace forge-discovery__get_skill_details with forge-discovery__get_skill. readPrompt shows version 6 created at 2026-07-24T16:47:18.739Z; searchPrompts("get_skill_details") returned zero results after the fix. | Yes |
| E2-E10 | — | Not auto-fixed in Verify because the findings exceed five items and include scope decisions about historical Output docs, architecture truth, and whether to revise Spec before implementation. | No |
User Disposition
-
Remove all files in Forge/Output, except for README.md and update the sidebar
-
Create a new Plan to resolve E2-E10
Run — 2026-07-31 (Post-Plan-8 Re-check)
Phase
Project: Forge/Knowledge_Consistency
Phase evaluated: Verify re-check after Plan 8 / Execute_Eval_8
Starting phase evidence: Knowledge_Consistency_Phase.md was Execute_Eval_8_Completed at handoff. The required Verify prior work-products Knowledge_Consistency_Vision.md and Knowledge_Consistency_Spec.md were present. Project directory listing showed Plans 1–8, Execute_State 1–8, and Execute_Eval 1–8 work-products present; the Phase gate log states Execute_Eval_8 completed and that all 8 Plan Execute→Execute_Eval cycles passed.
Verifier context: fresh Project Evaluator verification context for this re-check. The verification context read the Phase file, Project_Verify skill, Vision, Spec, Changelog, prior Verification report, Runs report, and direct grep/file-list evidence needed to test the first Verify findings. It did not read Research, Plan, Learnings, or Execute_State contents.
Disposition
Completed with findings. Findings E2–E10 from the 2026-07-24 Verify run are resolved after Plan 8 plus two minor Verify auto-fixes for residual MongoDB references found outside Plan 8’s target list.
The standard Verify build step did not pass in the current runtime because .internal Astro type-checking fails in src/components/Search.astro on virtual:starlight/docsearch-config and typesense-docsearch.js/dist/umd/index.js declarations. This is recorded as open infrastructure finding B1 and is outside the Knowledge Consistency Spec content corrections.
User Disposition (2026-08-01, interactive): B1 is rejected as outside this project’s completion criteria. The .internal Search.astro type-resolution failure is platform/infrastructure source code, not Knowledge Consistency markdown or skill content, and falls outside the Knowledge Consistency Spec correction scope. With B1 rejected and findings E2–E10 resolved, Verify is approved. Project proceeds to Extract.
Build / Commit / Push Evidence
- Start phase was set to
Verify_Started, committed as83f2d1c(Mark Knowledge Consistency verify started), and pushed toorigin/dev. - Start build command:
cd .internal && npm run build; result exit code 1. The generate step completed, thenastro checkfailed with twoSearch.astroerrors. - Re-check build command after auto-fixes:
cd .internal && npm run build; result exit code 1 with the same twoSearch.astroerrors. - Exact model token/cost data is unavailable from the current conversation tools; see
Knowledge_Consistency_Runs.mdfor available run/cost context.
Success Criteria
| # | Criterion | Measured by | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| V1 | All Forge Knowledge files reviewed | Checklist of every published .md file in Forge department root and Functions | 🟢 Success |
| V2 | All forge-group Bot system prompts reviewed | Checklist of every Bot in the “forge” group | 🟢 Success |
| V3 | All Forge Skills reviewed | Checklist of every SKILL.md in the Forge department | 🟢 Success |
| V4 | Deprecated items listed with file references | Itemized list with file path and removal recommendation | 🟢 Success |
| V5 | Outdated items listed with file references | Itemized list with file path, what’s outdated, and update recommendation | 🟢 Success |
| V6 | Inconsistencies listed with cross-references | Itemized list citing conflicting sources side by side | 🟢 Success |
| V7 | Omissions listed (documented-but-unimplemented and implemented-but-undocumented) | Itemized list with file references | 🟢 Success |
| V8 | Charter contradictions/omissions listed | Itemized list citing Charter section vs. conflicting source | 🟢 Success |
| V9 | Recommendations presented for user approval | Categorized findings document with recommended actions | 🟢 Success |
| V10 | Spec created for approved fixes | Spec document covering each approved recommendation | 🟢 Success |
Verification Evidence Summary
| Check Area | Evidence | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Phase gate | Phase began from Execute_Eval_8_Completed; all 8 Execute_Eval work-product files are present on disk. | 🟢 Pass |
| Required prior work-products | Knowledge_Consistency_Vision.md and Knowledge_Consistency_Spec.md are present. | 🟢 Pass |
| E2 target files | `grep -nE ‘MongoDB | mongodb |
| E2 broad residual check | Initial broad check found residual MongoDB references in Forge/Forge_Setup.md and Forge/Skills/Forge_Optimizer/references/example_report.md; both were mechanically auto-fixed. Post-fix broad check excluding project/archive/generated/build output and the intentional Choose_AI_Model model boundary returned no stale hits. | 🟢 Resolved |
| E3 | grep -n 'JWT Auth Manager' Forge/Forge_Infrastructure.md returned no hits. | 🟢 Pass |
| E4 | Obsolete get_skill_details / find_skill references were absent from the target files; current forge-discovery__* names remain. | 🟢 Pass |
| E5 | grep -n '/workspace/erik/uvilo-os/' Forge/Forge_Infrastructure.md Forge/Forge_Project/Skills/Project_Rename/SKILL.md returned no hits. | 🟢 Pass |
| E6 | Forge_Chat_Prompt.md was absent from the first-run target files after Plan 8. | 🟢 Pass |
| E7 | Follow the Manage Pages skill procedure was absent from Forge/Skills/Forge_Optimizer/references/example_report.md after Plan 8. | 🟢 Pass |
| E8 | gpt-5.4-nano, gpt-4o-mini, and max_completion_tokens were absent from Forge/Skills/Reindex_Typesense/SKILL.md and Forge/Skills/Typesense_MCP/SKILL.md; model-specific names remain only inside the intentional Choose_AI_Model boundary. | 🟢 Pass |
| E9 | Forge/Output no longer contains the first-run LibreChat-era Output documents; a stale-term grep over current Forge/Output returned no hits. | 🟢 Pass |
| E10 | Comprehensive stale-term search after auto-fix found no remaining stale references outside project/archive/generated/build output and the intentional Choose_AI_Model boundary. | 🟢 Pass |
| Standard Verify build | .internal build failed during astro check with Search.astro type errors unrelated to the Knowledge Consistency markdown/skill corrections. | 🔴 Open |
Items
| # | Type | Description | Status | Disposition |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| E2 | Defect | MongoDB references from the first Verify target files were removed. Two additional residual MongoDB references in Forge/Forge_Setup.md and Forge/Skills/Forge_Optimizer/references/example_report.md were found during this re-check and auto-fixed. | 🟢 Resolved | Fix |
| E3 | Defect | Forge_Infrastructure.md no longer documents JWT Auth Manager for session auth. | 🟢 Resolved | Fix |
| E4 | Defect | Forge_Infrastructure.md and Forge Optimizer reference examples no longer contain obsolete discovery tool names from the first Verify findings. | 🟢 Resolved | Fix |
| E5 | Defect | Incorrect /workspace/erik/uvilo-os/ references are absent from the first Verify target files. | 🟢 Resolved | Fix |
| E6 | Defect | Deprecated Forge_Chat_Prompt.md references are absent from the first Verify target files. | 🟢 Resolved | Fix |
| E7 | Defect | Direct Manage Pages skill routing text from the first Verify finding is absent from the Forge Optimizer reference example. | 🟢 Resolved | Fix |
| E8 | Defect | Model-specific references are absent from Reindex_Typesense and Typesense_MCP skills; model-specific names are isolated to Choose_AI_Model model references. | 🟢 Resolved | Fix |
| E9 | Variance | LibreChat-era Output documents identified in the first Verify run were removed; current Output content has no stale LibreChat/MongoDB/JWT/Forge_Chat_Prompt hits. | 🟢 Resolved | Fix |
| E10 | Gap | The post-Plan-8 broad stale-term search is clean after the two Verify auto-fixes, resolving the first Verify coverage gap. | 🟢 Resolved | Fix |
| B1 | Defect | Standard Verify build currently fails in .internal/src/components/Search.astro: TypeScript cannot resolve virtual:starlight/docsearch-config and lacks a declaration for typesense-docsearch.js/dist/umd/index.js. This was observed before and after the Verify auto-fixes and is not caused by the Knowledge Consistency markdown/skill edits. | 🔴 Rejected | Rejected as outside project completion criteria (user, 2026-08-01) |
Resolution Log
| # | Disposition | Action taken | Resolved |
|---|---|---|---|
| E2 residual A | Fix | Updated Forge/Forge_Setup.md to remove the explicit MongoDB example from the Railway Add Database sentence while preserving the Typesense deployment instruction. | Yes |
| E2 residual B | Fix | Updated Forge/Skills/Forge_Optimizer/references/example_report.md from “MongoDB message schema unknown” to “Conversation message schema unknown” and corrected the referenced path to Forge/Forge_Infrastructure.md. | Yes |
| E2-E10 | Fix | Re-ran targeted and broad stale-reference checks. No stale hits remain outside the project/archive/generated/build-output exclusions and the intentional Choose_AI_Model model-reference boundary. | Yes |
| B1 | Reject | User rejected B1 (2026-08-01) as outside the Knowledge Consistency project’s completion criteria — it is .internal platform source/type infrastructure unrelated to the Spec content corrections. No action taken within this project; Verify approved. | Yes (rejected) |
Next Step
B1 rejected as outside this project’s completion criteria (user disposition, 2026-08-01). Findings E2–E10 are resolved. Verify approved. Routing to Extract (Project Thinker).
Post-Commit Evidence
Verify re-check report, Runs update, phase completion, and direct auto-fixes were committed and pushed as 95670b7 (Complete Knowledge Consistency verify recheck).