Knowledge Consistency Execute Eval 2
Evaluation of Plan 2 implementation for Plan cycle 2.
Run — 2026-07-21
Phase
Execute_Eval_2
Agent / Session Context
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Department | Forge |
| Project | Forge/Knowledge_Consistency |
| Evaluator bot | forge/project-evaluator |
| Evaluator conversation | cnv_cmrv9jiun000101r2b9rm5re7 |
| Evaluated phase | Execute_2_Completed |
| Plan file | Forge/Projects/Knowledge_Consistency/Knowledge_Consistency_Plan_2.md |
| Execute state | Forge/Projects/Knowledge_Consistency/Knowledge_Consistency_Execute_State_2.md |
| Worker/reconciliation commit | 05dc543 — Plan 2 skill file content corrections |
| Evaluator auto-fix commit | 1cb8476 — Execute_Eval_2 auto-fix Plan 2 skill content gaps |
Verdict
Approved
Plan 2 execution now satisfies the Plan intent after evaluator auto-fix of three mechanical content gaps. No open findings remain.
Implementation Summary
| Task | Status | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Task 1 — Rename Orchestration Skill to Agentic_Prompts | ✅ | Forge/Skills/Agentic_Prompts/SKILL.md exists with name: Agentic_Prompts; references/ is populated; Forge/Skills/Orchestration/ no longer exists; deprecation language is absent. Sidebar content was not read directly because .internal/ source inspection is disallowed by the evaluator’s environment rules, but commit 05dc543 records .internal/astro.config.mjs as modified for the rename. |
| Task 2 — Update Update_Infrastructure Skill | ✅ | References uvilo-mono docs/deployment.md, prodRepoRoot, and uvilo-mono repository structure for deployment, database branching, migration, and environment configuration. Evaluator removed lingering MongoDB-specific persistence-check text in auto-fix commit 1cb8476. |
| Task 3 — Remove Forge_Chat_Prompt.md References from Skills | ✅ | No Forge_Chat_Prompt references remain under Forge/Skills/**/SKILL.md. Create_Skill Step 5 references the Persistent Knowledge database prompt. |
| Task 4 — Eliminate LibreChat References from MCP Skills | ✅ | Target MCP skills contain no librechat references. Vercel_MCP uses VERCEL_PROTECTION_BYPASS via /proc/1/environ. MCP_Development now references uvilo-mono’s MCP client after auto-fix commit 1cb8476. |
| Task 5 — Fix Filesystem Paths in Skills | ✅ | No /workspace/erik/uvilo-os/ references remain under Forge/Skills/**/SKILL.md. |
| Task 6 — Remove MongoDB References from Forge_Optimizer Skill | ✅ | No MongoDB references remain in Forge_Optimizer; evaluator also verified no MongoDB/MONGO_URI/pymongo/mongosh references remain under Forge/Skills/**/SKILL.md after auto-fix. |
| Task 7 — Replace Hardcoded Model Names with Use-Case Names in Skills | ✅ | No hardcoded model names remain outside Choose_AI_Model source/reference path references. Skills use use-case phrasing where model choice is procedural. |
| Task 8 — Remove Inline Model Quirks from Skills | ✅ | max_completion_tokens and temperature.*parameter inline quirk text is absent from affected skills. Forge_Optimizer, Reindex_Typesense, and Typesense_MCP reference Choose_AI_Model model reference files; Typesense_MCP now references both required model files after auto-fix commit 1cb8476. |
| Task 9 — Build, Commit, and Push | ✅ | Plan 2 implementation was committed/pushed in 05dc543; evaluator auto-fixes were committed/pushed in 1cb8476. Root npm run build was attempted during evaluation and failed with Missing script: "build", matching the Plan’s instruction to proceed despite expected build failure. |
Items
| # | Type | Description | Status | Disposition |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| E1 | Defect | Forge/Skills/Update_Infrastructure/SKILL.md still contained MongoDB-specific persistence-check guidance (MONGO_URI, authSource=admin, pymongo/mongosh), conflicting with Plan 2’s MongoDB-removal intent and completion criterion that no skills reference MongoDB. | 🟢 Resolved | Fix — Auto-dispositioned |
| E2 | Gap | Forge/Skills/MCP_Development/SKILL.md had no remaining LibreChat reference, but it also did not contain the Plan-required replacement phrase uvilo-mono's MCP client. | 🟢 Resolved | Fix — Auto-dispositioned |
| E3 | Gap | Forge/Skills/Typesense_MCP/SKILL.md referenced gpt-5.4-nano.md but not the Plan-required gpt-4o-mini.md model reference file. | 🟢 Resolved | Fix — Auto-dispositioned |
Resolution Log
| # | Disposition | Action taken | Resolved |
|---|---|---|---|
| E1 | Fix — Auto-dispositioned | Replaced MongoDB-specific persistence checklist text in Update_Infrastructure/SKILL.md with service-generic connection/auth wording tied to uvilo-mono deployment docs and repository structure. Committed in 1cb8476. | Yes |
| E2 | Fix — Auto-dispositioned | Replaced “current Bot/MCP tool layer” wording in MCP_Development/SKILL.md with uvilo-mono's MCP client. Committed in 1cb8476. | Yes |
| E3 | Fix — Auto-dispositioned | Updated Typesense_MCP/SKILL.md to reference both gpt-5.4-nano.md and gpt-4o-mini.md model reference files. Committed in 1cb8476. | Yes |
Verification Evidence
| Check | Result |
|---|---|
Phase gate: prior phase was Execute_2_Completed before evaluator routing to Execute_Eval_2_Started | ✅ |
Forge/Skills/Agentic_Prompts/SKILL.md exists with name: Agentic_Prompts | ✅ |
Forge/Skills/Agentic_Prompts/references/ exists and is populated | ✅ |
Forge/Skills/Orchestration/ no longer exists | ✅ |
| No deprecation wording in Agentic_Prompts SKILL.md | ✅ |
No outdated warning in Update_Infrastructure SKILL.md | ✅ |
Update_Infrastructure references docs/deployment.md, prodRepoRoot, and uvilo-mono repository structure | ✅ |
No Forge_Chat_Prompt references under Forge/Skills/**/SKILL.md | ✅ |
No librechat references in Linear_MCP, Suprsend_MCP, Vercel_MCP, or MCP_Development | ✅ |
Vercel_MCP references VERCEL_PROTECTION_BYPASS and /proc/1/environ | ✅ |
MCP_Development references uvilo-mono's MCP client | ✅ |
No /workspace/erik/uvilo-os/ references under Forge/Skills/**/SKILL.md | ✅ |
No mongodb, MongoDB/SKILL, MONGO_URI, pymongo, or mongosh references under Forge/Skills/**/SKILL.md | ✅ |
| No targeted hardcoded model names remain outside Choose_AI_Model path references | ✅ |
No max_completion_tokens in affected skills | ✅ |
No temperature.*parameter inline quirk text in affected skills | ✅ |
| Forge_Optimizer, Reindex_Typesense, and Typesense_MCP reference required Choose_AI_Model model reference locations | ✅ |
git rev-list --left-right --count @{u}...HEAD after auto-fix push | 0 0 |
Changelog Review
Knowledge_Consistency_Changelog.md had no change rows for Plan 2, so it could not be used as the primary changed-file checklist. The evaluator used git show --name-status 05dc543 instead. The changed-file set aligned with Plan 2 intent: the Agentic_Prompts rename/reference moves, target SKILL.md edits, project execute state update, and sidebar configuration update. No unexpected non-reference source files were identified.
Run / Cost Evidence
Exact token/cost data is unavailable in this session. Available run evidence: evaluator conversation cnv_cmrv9jiun000101r2b9rm5re7; Plan 2 implementation/reconciliation commit 05dc543; evaluator auto-fix commit 1cb8476; root build attempt during evaluation exited 1 with npm error Missing script: "build".
Next Step
Set Phase: Execute_Eval_2_Completed. Because Execute_Eval is not listed in human_gates, route autonomously to Execute Plan 3.