Knowledge Consistency Execute Eval 5

Evaluation of Plan 5 implementation for Plan cycle 5.

---

Run — 2026-07-22

Evaluation Context

Field	Value
Phase name	Execute_Eval_5
Department	Forge
Project	Forge/Knowledge_Consistency
Plan	Plan 5 — Forge Root Knowledge File Content Corrections
Evaluating bot / role	forge/project-evaluator
Skill	Project_Execute_Eval
Session	cnv_cmrw55494000001qp8xk8tb9g
Previous phase gate	Knowledge_Consistency_Phase.md showed Phase: Execute_5_Completed before evaluation began
Evaluation phase start	Evaluator set Phase: Execute_Eval_5_Started and pushed commit 146da31
Context boundary read	Plan 5, Execute_State_5, Learnings, Changelog, and Plan 5 implementation files named by the Plan/Changelog

Verdict

Approved.

Plan 5 execution satisfies the Plan intent and all completion criteria. No open defects, gaps, variances, or unresolved learnings were found. No auto-fix loop was needed.

Implementation Summary

Task	Status	Notes
Task 1 — Update Forge_Agent_Orchestration.md	✅ Pass	Removed stale Forge_Chat_Prompt reference, removed agent-sync terminology, no JWT Auth Manager references, discovery tool table uses the six Plan-specified forge-discovery__* names, and eager/deferred guidance references toolSearch/loadTool.
Task 2 — Update Forge_Infrastructure.md	✅ Pass	Removed context-inappropriate combined forgentic / uvilo-mono terminology, removed hardcoded gpt-5.4-nano and inline max_completion_tokens quirk text, and references the Choose_AI_Model model reference files/use-case table.
Task 3 — Update Forge_Agents_User_Guide.md	✅ Pass	Deprecated API names and slash-command references are absent; examples use spawnAgent, botId, message, and mode; no stale uvilo-mono terminology remains.
Task 4 — Fix filesystem paths in Forge_Setup.md	✅ Pass	Incorrect /workspace/erik/uvilo-os/ paths are absent; corrected /workspace/erik@uvilo.com/uvilo-os/ paths are present.
Task 5 — Add Bot prompt inspectability documentation	✅ Pass	Forge_Agent_Architecture.md documents application/vnd.prompt-version and describes loading version N and N−1 from the database to show a unified text diff.
Task 6 — Build, commit, and push	✅ Pass	Root npm run build fails because the repo root has no build script, as expected by Plan context; .internal build succeeds; Plan 5 execution commits are on origin/dev.

Completion Criteria Checklist

Criterion	Evidence	Result
Forge_Agent_Orchestration.md has no Forge_Chat_Prompt.md references	grep -Rin 'Forge_Chat_Prompt' Forge/Forge_Agent_Orchestration.md returned 0 matches	✅ Pass
Forge_Agent_Orchestration.md has no agent-sync terminology	grep -Rin 'agent-sync' Forge/Forge_Agent_Orchestration.md returned 0 matches	✅ Pass
Forge_Agent_Orchestration.md has no JWT Auth Manager references	grep -Rin 'JWT Auth Manager' Forge/Forge_Agent_Orchestration.md returned 0 matches	✅ Pass
Correct forge-discovery tool names present	Lines 128–133 list forge-discovery__list_departments, forge-discovery__list_dept_projects, forge-discovery__get_project, forge-discovery__list_skills, forge-discovery__get_skill, and forge-discovery__find	✅ Pass
Old discovery tool names absent	list_projects and get_skill_details returned 0 matches in Forge_Agent_Orchestration.md	✅ Pass
Eager/deferred guidance references toolSearch/loadTool	Lines 124 and 135 reference toolSearch and loadTool; no specific eager/deferred classification is asserted in the discovery section	✅ Pass
Orchestrator Service uses API-key authentication wording	Line 79 states API-key authentication (service account)	✅ Pass
Forge_Infrastructure.md has no combined forgentic / uvilo-mono terminology	grep -Rin 'forgentic / uvilo-mono' Forge/Forge_Infrastructure.md returned 0 matches	✅ Pass
Forge_Infrastructure.md has no hardcoded gpt-5.4-nano model name	grep -Rin 'gpt-5.4-nano' Forge/Forge_Infrastructure.md returned 0 matches	✅ Pass
Forge_Infrastructure.md has no inline max_completion_tokens quirks	grep -Rin 'max_completion_tokens' Forge/Forge_Infrastructure.md returned 0 matches	✅ Pass
Forge_Infrastructure.md references Choose_AI_Model model references	Line 119 references Forge/Skills/Choose_AI_Model/Models/ and the Choose_AI_Model Use Case Table	✅ Pass
Forge_Agents_User_Guide.md has no deprecated API patterns	Searches for spawn_agent, agent_id, task_prompt, agentId, taskPrompt, SCHEDULE_CONFIG, /spawn, /project-create, and gpt-4o returned 0 matches	✅ Pass
Forge_Agents_User_Guide.md uses current spawn pattern	Lines 117–139 and 297–303 use spawnAgent with current fields such as botId, message, and mode	✅ Pass
Forge_Agents_User_Guide.md has context-appropriate terminology	grep -Rin 'uvilo-mono' Forge/Forge_Agents_User_Guide.md returned 0 matches	✅ Pass
Forge_Setup.md has no incorrect /workspace/erik/uvilo-os/ paths	grep -Rin '/workspace/erik/uvilo-os/' Forge/Forge_Setup.md returned 0 matches	✅ Pass
Forge_Setup.md contains corrected paths	Correct /workspace/erik@uvilo.com/uvilo-os/ paths present at lines 66, 274, 285, and 472	✅ Pass
Forge_Agent_Architecture.md includes Bot prompt inspectability	Lines 72 and 185 document application/vnd.prompt-version	✅ Pass
Prompt inspectability section describes unified text diff between version N and N−1	Line 185 states the UI loads version N and N−1 from the database and displays a unified text diff	✅ Pass
Changes committed and pushed to dev	Plan 5 execution commit 343825e, changelog/phase commit f78b2ae, and eval-start commit 146da31 are contained in origin/dev	✅ Pass
Build verification	Repo-root npm run build failed with Missing script: "build"; .internal npm run build completed successfully with 934 pages built	✅ Pass
Working tree after evaluation checks	git status --short returned clean before report/status updates	✅ Pass

Items

#	Type	Description	Status	Disposition
E5-CLEAN	✅ Clean	No defects, gaps, variances, or unresolved learnings were found in Plan 5 execution against Plan intent and completion criteria.	🟢 Resolved	Approve

Resolution Log

#	Disposition	Action taken	Resolved
E5-CLEAN	Approve	No corrective action needed. Evaluation approved without auto-fix.	Yes

Learnings Review

Knowledge_Consistency_Learnings.md contains no Plan 5 learning entries requiring incorporation into permanent documentation.

Changelog Review

The Plan 5 rows in Knowledge_Consistency_Changelog.md match the expected implementation files:

File	Expected Plan 5 task	Changelog status
Forge_Agent_Orchestration.md	Task 1	✅ Present
Forge_Infrastructure.md	Task 2	✅ Present
Forge_Agents_User_Guide.md	Task 3	✅ Present
Forge_Setup.md	Task 4	✅ Present
Forge_Agent_Architecture.md	Task 5	✅ Present
Knowledge_Consistency_Execute_State_5.md	Execution state	✅ Present
Knowledge_Consistency_Phase.md	Phase routing	✅ Present

No unexpected Plan 5 implementation files were identified in the Changelog review.

Run / Cost Evidence

Exact token/cost data is unavailable in this evaluation session. Available run evidence:

• Evaluator conversation: cnv_cmrw55494000001qp8xk8tb9g
• Evaluation start commit: 146da31 (Start Execute_Eval 5 for Knowledge Consistency)
• Plan 5 execution commit: 343825e (Plan 5: Forge root knowledge file content corrections (S1.3, S1.5-S1.7, S4.1-S4.4, S7.2, S7.3, S8.2))
• Plan 5 changelog/phase commit: f78b2ae (Update Changelog with Plan 5 commit hash and set Phase to Execute_5_Completed)
• Build evidence: root npm run build failed with missing script; .internal npm run build succeeded and built 934 pages
• Git evidence: git branch -r --contains 343825e, git branch -r --contains f78b2ae, and git branch -r --contains 146da31 each included origin/dev

Next Step Instruction

Set Knowledge_Consistency_Plan_5.md and Knowledge_Consistency_Execute_State_5.md frontmatter to status: approved, set Knowledge_Consistency_Phase.md to Phase: Execute_Eval_5_Completed, then proceed autonomously to Execute Plan 6 because Execute_Eval is not listed in human_gates.