Forge Project Cleanup Spec Eval

Evaluation of Spec for Forge_Project_Cleanup.

---

Evaluation Context

Field	Value
Phase	Spec_Eval
Run date	2026-06-26
Agent / session	Project Evaluator, fresh independent review session
Department	Forge
Project	Forge_Project_Cleanup
Vision	Forge/Projects/Forge_Project_Cleanup/Forge_Project_Cleanup_Vision.md
Research	Forge/Projects/Forge_Project_Cleanup/Forge_Project_Cleanup_Research.md
Spec	Forge/Projects/Forge_Project_Cleanup/Forge_Project_Cleanup_Spec.md
Skill	project-spec-eval
Auto-fix round	1
Thinker fix commit	125399ef7e1e2ba312cf44f2d1ff1535497b77f8

Verdict

Approved.

Checklist

#	Checklist Item	Result	Note
1	Every requirement addressed	✅	R1-R9 are all mapped in the Requirement Traceability table and have substantive Spec sections.
2	No orphan sections	✅	Sections trace to Vision requirements or approved Research correction constraints.
3	Declarative	✅	The Spec describes target state, behaviors, guarantees, inventories, and evidence rather than implementation steps.
4	Self-contained	✅	The Spec now defines both the filesystem-safe {ProjectSlug} path convention and the exact human_gates storage schema in Phase-file frontmatter.
5	No internal contradictions	✅	The canonical project identifier {Department}/{ProjectShortName} is distinct from the filesystem-safe {ProjectSlug}, resolving the slash/path contradiction.
6	Research decisions reflected	✅	The five approved Research correction constraints are reflected: todos, WIP removal, work-product communication, handoff/phase ownership, and Charter controls.
7	Success criteria achievable	✅	V8 and V9 are achievable after the Spec clarifies filesystem-safe naming and human gate persistence.
8	Naming consistent	✅	Canonical/display identifiers, {ProjectShortName}, and {ProjectSlug} are defined and used consistently.
9	Exact content preserved	✅	No Research or Vision prompt/config/message exact text requiring References/ preservation is paraphrased as implementation content.
10	No hidden scope	✅	Human gate persistence is explicit: human_gates is a top-level YAML frontmatter list in the existing Phase file.

Items

#	Type	Description	Status	Disposition
E1	Defect	Section 11 made the department-qualified project identifier {Department}/{ProjectShortName} apply to project folder names and work-product file names. Since / is a path separator, this was internally inconsistent and left implementers without a filesystem-safe naming rule.	🟢 Resolved	Fix
E2	Gap	Section 12 said human gate selections were recorded in “the project Phase file or a dedicated configuration section,” leaving a hidden implementation choice and ambiguous target configuration shape.	🟢 Resolved	Fix

Disposition values: Fix | Update spec | Reject | Defer to future cycle | Change requested by user

Status values: 🔴 Open | 🟡 In progress | 🟢 Resolved

Resolution Log

#	Disposition	Action taken	Resolved
E1	Fix	Project Thinker added a canonical/display identifier vs filesystem-safe {ProjectSlug} distinction and clarified path/file-name usage.	Yes
E2	Fix	Project Thinker selected the existing Phase file as the storage location and defined human_gates as a top-level YAML frontmatter list with exact gate values and defaults.	Yes

Build / Commit Evidence

Step	Evidence
Initial Spec Eval report and sidebar	Report committed in eb9ec55; sidebar committed in f46e620; build passed in Page Manager run.
Auto-fix	Spec fix committed and pushed in 125399ef7e1e2ba312cf44f2d1ff1535497b77f8; build passed with cd .internal && pnpm run build.
Final evaluator update	Final report and phase completion built, committed, and pushed after this report update.

Next-Step Instruction

Set Phase: Spec_Eval_Completed. The Spec is approved for the next autonomous phase, Plan, subject to normal Runner routing and any configured human gate behavior.