Evaluation of knowledge extraction for the Knowledge Consistency project.
Run — 2026-08-01
| Field | Value |
|---|
| Phase | Extract_Eval |
| Project | Forge/Knowledge_Consistency |
| Agent/session context | Project Evaluator, fresh Extract_Eval session |
| Skill | Project_Extract_Eval (Forge/Forge_Project/Skills/Project_Extract_Eval/SKILL.md) |
| Prior phase confirmed | Phase: Extract_Completed in Knowledge_Consistency_Phase.md before this evaluation started |
| Required prior work-products | Knowledge_Consistency_Vision.md and Knowledge_Consistency_Spec.md present |
| Context boundary | Read Vision, Spec, Changelog, extracted permanent docs, and required findability prompt/skill evidence. Did not read Research, Plans, Learnings, or Execute_State files for extraction evaluation. |
| Build evidence | Initial root npm run build reported missing root build script; fallback npx astro build failed because it used an external Astro install and could not resolve astro/entrypoints/prerender. Correct repo build from .internal with npm run build succeeded. |
| Commit evidence | Extract started commit: 4eb8b29; Extract_Eval sidebar commit: afbd625; Extract_Eval report commit: c892dc8; extraction content under review: 35675b0. |
| Run/cost evidence | Exact token/cost evidence unavailable in this session. Available evidence: this Extract_Eval report, command outputs, database prompt read for Persistent Knowledge prompt prm_cmq83857c000101mzrhmopc03, and git commits recorded here. |
Verdict
Approved
| Learning | Destination | Status |
|---|
Frontmatter convention: required fields are title, visibility, status, owner, and approver; date fields are sourced from git/filesystem and are not maintained in frontmatter | Forge/Forge_Document_Structure.md → ## Frontmatter Convention; cross-referenced from Forge/Forge_Project/Forge_Project_Workflow.md §14 | ✅ |
Infrastructure file convention: AGENTS.md is canonical context; README.md is optional and eliminated where content overlaps with AGENTS.md | Forge/Forge_Document_Structure.md → ## Infrastructure Files | ✅ |
| Project workflow frontmatter convention de-duplicated and aligned with the permanent document-structure convention | Forge/Forge_Project/Forge_Project_Workflow.md §14 | ✅ |
Terminology convention: uvilo-mono is the monorepo; forgentic is the Railway-deployed app/runtime | Forge/Forge_Infrastructure.md → ## Terminology | ✅ |
| Bot prompt inspectability reference | Already permanently documented in Forge/Forge_Agent_Architecture.md → Artifact Instructions (application/vnd.prompt-version, unified text diff) | ✅ |
| Choose AI Model convention | Already permanently documented in Forge/Skills/Choose_AI_Model/SKILL.md | ✅ |
| Changelog/Runs conventions and phase-state rules | Already permanently documented in Forge/Forge_Project/Forge_Project_Workflow.md | ✅ |
| Available Skills list | Verified in Persistent Knowledge prompt prm_cmq83857c000101mzrhmopc03; 24 published skills represented, with retired/draft MCP skills excluded | ✅ |
| Department-level findability | Forge/AGENTS.md links to Forge_Project_Workflow.md, Forge_Infrastructure.md, and Forge_Document_Structure.md; all extracted knowledge files have status: published | ✅ |
Checklist
| Check | Evidence | Result |
|---|
| All extractable knowledge reached a permanent home | Changelog and Spec-derived extraction targets map to permanent docs/skill/prompt locations listed in Extraction Summary | ✅ Pass |
| No useful information remains trapped in the project folder | Project reference filenames are represented by permanent homes: Bot_Prompt_Inspectability.md, Changelog_Format.md, Choose_AI_Model_Skill.md, Eager_Deferred_Guidance.md, and Terminology_Context.md are absorbed in the permanent docs/skills/prompts above | ✅ Pass |
| Extracted content is self-contained | Extracted sections do not require the Knowledge_Consistency project folder, project Spec IDs, or project reference files to be understood | ✅ Pass |
| No improper duplication between Knowledge files | Forge_Document_Structure.md owns the full frontmatter convention; Forge_Project_Workflow.md §14 is a short pointer/reference. Terminology definition appears in Forge_Infrastructure.md rather than being repeated across multiple Knowledge files | ✅ Pass |
| Everything is findable | Extracted docs are status: published, linked from Forge/AGENTS.md, and the Available Skills list was verified in the Persistent Knowledge prompt | ✅ Pass |
| Work-product communication | Findings, evidence, verdict, build/run context, and next-step instruction are persisted in this durable report | ✅ Pass |
Items
| # | Type | Description | Status | Disposition |
|---|
| C1 | ✅ Clean | No extraction defects, gaps, variances, or new learnings remained open after review. | 🟢 Resolved | Approved |
Resolution Log
| # | Disposition | Action taken | Resolved |
|---|
| C1 | Approved | No auto-fix loop required; extraction review was clean. | ✅ |
Next Step
Set Knowledge_Consistency_Phase.md to Phase: Extract_Eval_Completed. Because Extract_Eval is not listed in human_gates, no human gate todo is required and no next autonomous agent is spawned by this evaluator. The project is ready for completion routing outside this evaluator’s phase ownership.
