Knowledge Consistency Execute Eval 1
Evaluation of Plan 1 implementation for Plan cycle 1.
Run — 2026-07-19
Verdict
Approved.
Plan 1 execution satisfies the Plan 1 intent: create the Choose_AI_Model skill, create five model reference files, add the sidebar entry through Page Manager, and commit/push the work to dev.
Evaluation Context
| Field | Value |
|---|
| Department | Forge |
| Project | Forge/Knowledge_Consistency |
| Phase Evaluated | Execute_Eval_1 |
| Plan Evaluated | Plan 1 — Choose_AI_Model Skill Creation |
| Evaluator Role | Project Evaluator, fresh session |
| Execute Session | cnv_cmrs93hhr008a01o6eviuqn4e |
| Page Manager Session | cnv_cmrs9d6qg008b01o656t3fsxr |
| Phase Gate | Previous phase Execute_1_Completed confirmed in Knowledge_Consistency_Phase.md; current phase was Execute_Eval_1_Started at evaluation start |
| Skill Used | project-execute-eval |
Context Boundary Check
| Input | Result |
|---|
| Current Plan | Read Knowledge_Consistency_Plan_1.md |
| Current Execute State | Read Knowledge_Consistency_Execute_State_1.md |
| Learnings | No *Learn* file found in Forge/Projects/Knowledge_Consistency/ |
| Changelog | No project Changelog file found in Forge/Projects/Knowledge_Consistency/; References/Changelog_Format.md exists but is a reference spec, not an execution changelog |
| Current/Previous Execute_Eval report | No previous Knowledge_Consistency_Execute_Eval_1.md report existed before this run |
| Plan-listed implementation artifacts | Reviewed the created Choose_AI_Model skill and five Models/ files; used the Plan-listed affected files only to verify the documented model quirks were represented |
Implementation Summary
| Task | Status | Notes |
|---|
| Task 1 — Create the Choose_AI_Model Skill | ✅ | Forge/Skills/Choose_AI_Model/SKILL.md exists with name: Choose_AI_Model, a five-row use-case table, Decision Procedure, Convention, and Model Reference Files section. |
| Task 2 — Create Model Reference Files | ✅ | Models/ contains the five planned files: gpt-5.4-nano.md, gpt-4o-mini.md, glm-5.2.md, gpt-5.4.md, and gpt-5.5.md. Each file documents provider, context/cost fields, quirks or strengths, and recommended use cases. |
| Task 3 — Build, Commit, and Push | ✅ | Root npm run build fails as expected because the root package.json has no build script. Commits 6b3dda3, 7f9cf2d, 2fd6271, a17b4bb, 2db395b, and runner commit 85ebc1a are on dev; local dev was even with origin/dev at evaluation start. |
| Sidebar entry | ✅ | Execute State records Page Manager sync session cnv_cmrs9d6qg008b01o656t3fsxr, duplicate sidebar cleanup, successful Astro build from Page Manager, and pushed sidebar commits 6b3dda3 and 7f9cf2d. Evaluator did not read .internal/ directly per repository rules. |
Changed-Work Checklist
| File | Evaluation Result |
|---|
Forge/Skills/Choose_AI_Model/SKILL.md | Matches Plan 1 Task 1 and the Plan-referenced Choose_AI_Model specification. |
Forge/Skills/Choose_AI_Model/Models/gpt-5.4-nano.md | Includes the required max_completion_tokens >= 300 and rejected temperature quirks, plus recommended use cases. |
Forge/Skills/Choose_AI_Model/Models/gpt-4o-mini.md | Includes the index-time summary use case/quirk and legacy forge-indexing recommendation. |
Forge/Skills/Choose_AI_Model/Models/glm-5.2.md | Documents provider, routing/classification strength, recommended use case, and clearly marks unavailable current context/pricing for verification rather than fabricating it. |
Forge/Skills/Choose_AI_Model/Models/gpt-5.4.md | Documents OpenAI provider, reasoning/execution strengths, pricing tiers, and forge-thinker/forge-executor recommendations. |
Forge/Skills/Choose_AI_Model/Models/gpt-5.5.md | Documents provider, evaluator use case, and clearly marks unavailable current context/pricing for verification rather than fabricating it. |
| Sidebar config | Execute State and Page Manager evidence show the entry was added and duplicate entry removed. |
Knowledge_Consistency_Execute_State_1.md | Durable execution record contains task checklist, changed files, verification results, commits, build result, anomaly note, and run/cost evidence. |
Knowledge_Consistency_Phase.md | Phase gate log confirms Execute_1_Completed before evaluation routing. |
Items
| # | Type | Description | Status | Disposition |
|---|
| — | ✅ Clean | No defects, gaps, unresolved variances, or learnings requiring incorporation were found for Plan 1. Pricing/context fields for glm-5.2 and gpt-5.5 are explicitly marked for verification instead of fabricated, which is acceptable under the Plan wording to use available documentation. | 🟢 Resolved | Approved |
Resolution Log
| # | Disposition | Action taken | Resolved |
|---|
| — | Approved | No auto-fix loop required; no open findings remained. | Yes |
Build and Git Evidence
| Check | Result |
|---|
| Evaluator root build command | npm run build from /workspace/erik@uvilo.com/uvilo-os returned Missing script: "build", matching the Plan’s Known Infrastructure Context. |
| Git branch/upstream | dev tracking origin/dev |
| Git sync at evaluation start | git rev-list --left-right --count @{u}...HEAD returned 0 0 |
| Recent relevant commits | 6b3dda3 content/sidebar, 7f9cf2d sidebar dedupe, 2fd6271 Execute State sidebar entry, a17b4bb / 2db395b execution state and phase records, 85ebc1a runner routing to Execute_Eval_1 |
Run / Cost Evidence
Exact USD run cost is unavailable from the tooling. Available evidence: executing conversation cnv_cmrs93hhr008a01o6eviuqn4e; Page Manager sync conversation cnv_cmrs9d6qg008b01o656t3fsxr; date 2026-07-19; pushed commits listed above; evaluator build command and git sync checks recorded in this report. Execute State reports Page Manager sub-agent token usage of approximately 1.03M input tokens, 27.5K output tokens, and 24K reasoning tokens, but no USD cost.
Next Step
Set Plan 1 and Execute State 1 frontmatter to approved, set this report frontmatter to approved, set project phase to Execute_Eval_1_Completed, create the optimizer reminder todo, then route autonomously to Execute Plan 2 because Execute_Eval is not in this project’s human_gates.
